Transition from Village Republics to Smart Cities in Gandhian Thought
Main Article Content
Abstract
The history of the Indian nation is based essentially on a struggle between two opposite directions of what an ideal society should be. The village was a strategic one, long in years, not only because a great number of Indians lived there, but as a moral and political centre. Gandhi based his idea of Gram Swaraj upon the principle that genuine self-rule begins in our communities and that they make what they consume and that it is more democratic when its people know each other well. Decentralization was not a strategy, but an ideology. Smart cities imply quite a different notion. Their usage is efficient, linked, rich in information, and organised mostly at the top tier. The clever traffic management systems in Pune and the single command centers in Bhopal are quite amazing. Nevertheless, they operate in systems where decisions are made by authorities and computer algorithms, not village councils. The question that this paper is discussing is whether this transformation is a betrayal of Gandhian ideals or something a bit more subtle perhaps that it is an evolution and is uncomfortable and even flawed however not completely disconnected. The paper will be based on the findings of political theory, urban planning, and development studies, and how these two models actually conflict and in which cases, surprisingly, they might coincide. Both claim that they focus on citizen welfare and sustainable resources, for instance. The methods are very different. The concern is real, however. Unless these concepts, such as equity and ecological responsibility are explicitly included, smart city projects can contribute to intensifying the inequalities they are meant to alleviate. More promising is the new concept of smart villages - integrating, rather than substituting, digital tools within decentralized and community-based structures. Ultimately, the message is that India does not have to make a choice between Gandhi and gigabytes. Finding a way to work out how to deal with the two is more difficult and interesting.