Importance-Performance Analysis to Prioritize and Analyze the Comprehensive Pattern of the Drivers of Internal Audit Effectiveness in Iranian Commercial Banks

Main Article Content

Hessam Dirin
Mostafa Ghasemi
Abdolreza Mohseni

Abstract

Subject In this study, the factors affecting the effectiveness of internal controls in Iranian commercial banks were identified and prioritized based on the Importance-performance analysis matrix. Research Method The method of this qualitative research is "grounded theory"; for this purpose, focus groups were first used before the research and conducting background interviews. Therefore, fifteen internal audit managers with relevant experience were invited, then the insights gained from the focus group interviews were used to develop and improve the interview guide. The research sample in the qualitative section was provided to 10 professors and experts in the field of accounting and auditing and internal auditors and supervisors of banks, and resulted in the preparation of a questionnaire for interviews. The face and content validity of this tool was approved by experts and its reliability was calculated to be 70 percent, and the data were analyzed using the exploratory factor analysis method. Then, the themes were prioritized based on the importanceperformance analysis method. Discussion plan In this study, an attempt was made to determine the subjective meanings of the studied stakeholders of the effectiveness of internal auditing in Iranian commercial banks and the effective determination of the effectiveness of auditing in Iranian commercial banks, based on the perspective of the studied stakeholders, and the consequences of the effectiveness of internal auditing in Iranian commercial banks, based on the perspective of the studied stakeholders. The results showed that the subjective meanings and factors affecting the effectiveness of auditing are obtained and can be classified based on five categories as follows: Human resources and competencies, organizational structure and independence, audit processes and quality improvement, management and organizational support, facilities and legal frameworks. Conclusion Based on the results of this study, commercial banks can focus on identifying factors affecting the effectiveness of internal audit in the form of issues such as staff, internal audit system, management and organizational facilities, accepting stakeholders' opinions, and trying to use reliable and quality information from the accounting system.

Article Details

Section
Articles