Who Decides When AI Recommends? An S-O-R Analysis of Consumer Autonomy in Algorithmic Choice Environments

Main Article Content

Surbhi Choudhary
Damanjit Kour

Abstract

Artificial intelligence driven recommendation systems are increasingly embedded in digital consumer decision environments. While these systems enhance efficiency and personalization, they also raise concerns related to consumer autonomy and perceived control. Drawing on the Stimulus-Organism-Response (S-O-R) framework, this study examines how key algorithmic design features influence consumer psychological states and behavioral outcomes. A controlled online experiment employing a 2 (personalization intensity: low vs. high) × 2 (transparency: low vs. high) × 2 (choice freedom: restricted vs. broad) betweensubjects design was conducted. Personalization intensity, transparency, and choice freedom were conceptualized as environmental stimuli, while perceived autonomy, perceived competence, and trust represented organismic states influencing consumer responses. The results demonstrate that perceived autonomy plays a central mediating and boundary-defining role in algorithmic decision contexts. High personalization enhances choice acceptance, decision satisfaction, and willingness to pay only when consumers perceive sufficient autonomy. When choice freedom is restricted, increased personalization triggers resistance and lowers satisfaction. Transparency positively influences trust and perceived competence; however, its effectiveness diminishes under restrictive choice architectures. The findings suggest that firms should design AI-based recommendation systems that balance personalization with meaningful choice freedom and transparent algorithmic cues to preserve consumer autonomy and trust. This study extends the S-O-R framework to AI-mediated consumption by demonstrating the pivotal role of perceived autonomy in shaping consumer responses to algorithmic recommendations, offering both theoretical advancement and actionable guidance for ethical AI design.

Article Details

Section
Articles